Oysters from the Great South Bay

Sustainably Harvested. Unmatched Freshness.

Place an order today

Private Events Serviced - Call Today!

(631) 319-7660

Home Grown by Heroes – Certified Veteran-Farmed Produce and Products.

New York State Grown & Certified – Assurance of Locally Sourced and High-Quality Products.

Oysters cultured in Great South Bay, known for their rich flavor and quality.

About us

Meet the Faces Behind Toasted Oysters

In 2023, Ray and Mike, two friends with a shared passion for the sea, embarked on a new journey in oyster farming. They founded Toasted Oysters on the Great South Bay, dedicated to cultivating authentic Blue Point Oysters. Our oysters are a testament to our commitment to sustainability and quality, rooted in the rich maritime history of Long Island. With every harvest, we uphold the tradition of delivering the freshest, most authentic oysters to our customers.

Place an order today

Ray and Mike – Two Individuals Posing Together.

Our Oysters

Blue Point oysters are a renowned variety of Atlantic oysters originally harvested from the Great South Bay in Blue Point, Long Island, New York. Known for their balanced, briny flavor with a hint of sweetness and a firm texture, they have become a popular choice among oyster enthusiasts. Today, "Blue Point" refers to oysters cultivated in various parts of Long Island and along the East Coast, maintaining their reputation for quality and fresh, oceanic taste. These oysters are prized for their smooth, clean finish and are often enjoyed raw on the half shell.

Half a dozen fresh oysters served on a platter, perfect for seafood lovers.

12 Oysters

$21.00

Order Now

A dozen fresh oysters served on a platter, perfect for seafood lovers.

36 Oysters

$60.00

Order Now

A platter of 50 fresh oysters served on ice, ready to enjoy.

50 Oysters

$80.00

Order Now

Why Choose Us?

Toasted Oysters offers the freshest, authentic Blue Point oysters, harvested from the Great South Bay. As a veteran-owned business, we prioritize quality, sustainability, and community. Our commitment to authentic, locally grown oysters ensures an exceptional taste experience. Choose us for oysters that truly stand out.

Authentic Blue Point Oysters

We are proud to offer the only true Blue Point oysters, harvested right from their original waters in the Great South Bay. Unlike others, our oysters are cultivated and grown in their natural habitat, ensuring unmatched flavor and quality.

Locally Grown and Sustainable

As a New York State Grown and Certified farm and a member of the Home Grown by Heroes program, we are committed to sustainable farming practices. Our oysters are farmed with care, respecting the environment and supporting local ecosystems.

Unmatched Freshness

Our oysters are harvested daily to ensure they reach your plate as fresh as possible. We believe that every oyster should tell the story of the waters it came from, and we work tirelessly to bring that experience to you.